Categories

Why WoW Players Should Switch to WAR - A Rebuttal

Oct. 4 12:25 PM by Crimson N Clover

While perusing my daily tid-bits of random gaming information I came across something that made me audibly gasp: An article on GamesRadar.com entitled Why WoW players should switch to WAR.

Everything I have heard about Warhammer Online is that it is basically terrible. Yes, it is similar to WoW, but it takes away all the things I personally love about WoW, and amplifies all the things I dislike.

I do not PvP. I mean, I have, and sure, I most definitely enjoy jumping on my hunter and brutally massacring hundreds of people from behind a tree; topping the dps/kb charts in welfare epics and quest blues. I have even been known to laugh maniacally in arenas as my partner reeks havoc on a team, while I throw my overpowered HoTs and cyclone/root to my hearts content; but when it comes down to it, I do not have a real thirst for blood. I do not wake up in the morning and think "I wonder who I am going to kill today?"

Therefore, a game like Warhammer, in all its PvP glory, never intrigued me. But, the author of the aforementioned article would have us think otherwise. Though, after actually reading it, I am inclined to grab a large stick and beat him with it... Ok, so sometimes I am a little blood thirsty.

Nagata goes on for 3 pages, listing why WAR is better, but in many cases, I tend to disagree. He says things like:

You won't 'dance' like Napoleon Dynamite in WAR. There are more important things for you to do, like killing other players

I like the cheesy dances. I admittedly rarely type /dance. On occasion I will log on my random Night Elf alt and do a little jig to impress a friend in to playing, and I have been known to drink a Noggin Fogger elixir and rock out as a skeleton; but for the most part, I do not like dancing for its style, I like it for what it says about the game: Warcraft does not take itself too seriously. WoW has terrible graphics and it knows it.

One of the largest gripes I have heard about Warhammer is that it has the same graphics as WoW, but tries to make everything look realistic, and in that, it fails. The characters come off looking, as my friend who played states, "too pixelated and incomplete".

WAR streamlines the grouping process so that joining parties, finding a large war band of players for PvP, and joining a guild isn't reserved for those who are close to reaching their level cap.

I can understand why this would seem like a good thing, but I personally like the good ole end game guilds. WoW has its fair share of random low level guilds *Queue Illegal Danish* "Wanna join my guild?!" The idea behind elitist guilds is mostly so that you are not stuck with people who do not know what they are doing. If you, like me, are not a fan of PuGs, then WAR is the devil; which brings me to this:

Since all groups are Open Groups by default, this means that you'll almost always find some friendly group to grind or PvP with.

NOOOOOOOOO!!! Ugh, flabbergast and disgust. I am deathly allergic to PuGs, having had one too many terrible experiences with them. I do not get off on joining random people who may or may not know how to press a button, who may or may not be a 10 year old who thinks fart jokes are hilarious, who may or may not blurt the ever tiresome "Oh em gee, yur a gurl?!"... You get my point. I understand my hatred of PuGs is a little extreme and outlandish (giggle, Outland), but that does not make me any more willing to voluntarily play a game that I know at any moment will throw me, against my will, into a Russian roulette style pick-up group.

Aside from all that, WAR looks pretty great. The PvP aspect looks amazing and the open world questing seems pretty nifty. Though I still feel that Warhammer Online is a game that eats, breaths and sleeps PvP. I personally do not want to have my morning bowl of PvP drenched in PvP, with a healthy glass or two of PvP and a side of, you guessed it, PvP. If you are annoyed by the term "PvP' yet, then you can remotely grasp my distaste for a game solely revolving around... PvP.

With an upgrade to graphics, and a larger fan base, it could very well compete with World of Warcraft (I cringe waiting for the WoW gods to smite me down).

I do not, however, think that us die hard World of Warcraft fans should up and leave. At this point Warhammer can not compare to the vast awesomeness and hours of mindless entertainment that WoW brings to the table. It has a lot of growing up to do before I actually cancel my age-old Warcraft account and move on to new waters.

No matter what my opinion, it seems the only way to solve my curiosity for whether the game is indeed terrible or the best thing since sliced bread is to buy it.

Before I run off to Gamestop and pick up a copy of my own, what are everyone else's opinions on the game? Who is playing it, and is it truly better than WoW? Will I begin spending my 15 bucks a month on a new "W" titled MMO?

Happy gaming,

CnC

Comments

I have to agree on all the points you made. Warhammer is incredibly PvP centric - from what I have heard, the questing structure dies off around level 20ish, and you are left to do the rest of your leveling via PvP combat. But I am not at all surprised by this - that was exactly how Dark Age of Camelot was structured, and considering the same team built Warhammer, well, similarities are bound to occur.

And personally, its WoW's elaborate (and often pun-tastic) sense of humor that keeps me questing well after I hit lvl 70. The /dance's and /silly's add immense amounts of personality to the world, and to have them stripped out would be a crime against humanity (or whatever race you may be).

While I haven't directly played Warhammer as of yet, I have watched someone play it, and my overall reaction is that I am incredibly unimpressed. To me, it looked like they stripped the core mechanics of Warcraft back to a pre-beta state, and gave it the graphics of Lord of the Rings Online. It doesn't feel like a cohesive world, but a world duct-taped together and sprinkled with quest NPCs simply because they were forced at gunpoint to add them.

But thats just my opinion.

 

I'm working on the omgRPG WAR review currently...so look for that soon!

 

I was actually going to write a longer response to this article, but I think the line: "I do not PvP." sums it up best.

This game is not for you. It is for me. When I get ready to play, I say, "Well, time to go kill people." Not. "Well, time to go grind endlessly on mobs." My friends would beat ME with a stick if I said such a thing.
I think it is great that you enjoy PvE. I don't. I want to jump in and kill people from the start. I get to do that with WAR. I have enjoyed lvl 5, lvl 10, lvl 15, lvl 20. It's all fun. I have no mad-dash desire to rush to max level (they need to add the ability to turn xp off like in DAOC). THAT is what WoW missed. I actually PAID people to level my character in WoW just because the low level stuff was that boring. Never with WAR. Goodbye raids. Goodbye equipment grinds. I am happy.
- LC

 

You must be registered and logged in to leave comments.

If you are already have a login with GamePro.com, Gamerhelp.com, Games.net or GameProFamily.com, then use that login!